Koizumi’s adieu

The Koizumi restoration
Sep 14th 2006 From The Economist print editionJapan’s remarkable prime minister is about to stand down. Will his revolution last?

IT HAS been a thrilling show, but now it is over. On September 20th Japan’s Liberal Democratic Party will elect a new leader to replace Junichiro Koizumi, who will formally stand down as prime minister at the end of the month. He is leaving, undefeated at the polls and still popular after five and a half years in the job, only because of term limits imposed by his own party’s constitution. But in that brief time he has done more to “change the LDP, change Japan”, to quote his best slogan, than any politician of his generation.
Mr Koizumi’s achievement is threefold . First, he has changed the way politics is carried out in a country that used in effect to be a secretive one-party state, whose leaders emerged from obscure battles between factions convening in smoke- and sake-filled rooms far away from voters’ eyes. Mr Koizumi, a rank underdog, snatched the leadership in 2001 only after a huge popular vote from party members forced the hands of the party bosses. He went on to win four elections by appealing, in a way that no Japanese politician had ever even attempted, directly to the electorate. His shaggy hair and natural charisma were refreshing in a party best known for conformity. Most startling of all for Japan, he favoured making big economic reforms.
Those reforms, the second component of his achievement, have probably been a disappointment to him. Stubbornly resisted by his own party, they have been delayed and partial—most notoriously in the case of the privatisation of Japan’s postal savings system, which has too often been a way for politicians to direct citizens’ savings to favoured contractors. But at least Mr Koizumi began the work of breaking up the “iron triangle”—big business, bureaucracy, LDP—making government a bit more accountable, reining in profligate and inefficient spending and in the process starting to tackle Japan’s mountainous public-sector debt.
Partially successful, too, has been Mr Koizumi’s quest to let Japan start to play the part it deserves in foreign affairs, his third claim to a place in history. He sent peacekeepers to Iraq, the boldest venture by Japanese troops for half a century, and has worked hard with America to make Japan depend less on America’s military umbrella and shoulder more of the burden of its own defence. But he has not succeeded at what ought to have been his priority: the rewriting of Japan’s constitution, which renounces war, to assert Japan’s right to participate in collective security. At present Japan’s peacekeepers are highly constrained, and cannot legally use their firepower to help defend foreign civilians or assist their allies.
A qualified record then, but the point of Mr Koizumi’s stint in office is that he has for the first time challenged the comfortable assumptions that have governed Japan since the war. He has attacked entrenched power: of the LDP’s own party bosses, of the bureaucrats, and of the victors of 1945, who imposed pacifism on Japan. The big question, however, is whether any of this has changed for good. Perhaps Mr Koizumi is just a latter-day version of the Meiji emperor who, in the late 1860s, wrested power from the shoguns (feudal lords who had usurped it) and set Japan on the path of modernisation. The “Meiji restoration” did not last long: a new band of oligarchs and militarists swiftly gathered real power back.
In the case of China, proceed with caution
Mr Koizumi’s successor, it now seems certain, will be Shinzo Abe, currently Japan’s chief cabinet secretary. Like Mr Koizumi before him, he is more or less untested and, at 51, relatively young. But he shows little sign of being an iconoclast. Though Mr Abe is a protégé of Mr Koizumi’s, and is generally numbered in the reformist camp, he has not been one of its truly courageous battlers. Nor does he have much of Mr Koizumi’s charisma. The danger therefore exists that he will be able neither to enthuse Japan’s voters in the way Mr Koizumi did, nor use personal popularity to force his still-reluctant party further down the road of reform.
One area where Mr Abe’s reforming zeal may exceed Mr Koizumi’s is in international relations. He has already committed himself to rewriting the constitution. But the trick is to do this without sending Japan’s relations with China into a tailspin. Japan and China are each other’s biggest trading partners, and under Mr Koizumi relations have been bad—in part because of Mr Koizumi’s provocative habit of visiting the controversial Yasukuni shrine, and in part because China detests Japan’s ambition to play a bigger role. Mr Abe is a hawk who entertains dark suspicions about China. He has also been a regular visitor to Yasukuni. If he stays away from the shrine and makes an early fence-mending mission to China, he could do much for Japan’s standing in the world. If not, he risks squandering the legacy of a remarkable prime minister.


One response to “Koizumi’s adieu

  1. Abe poised to become Japan’s new PM Tue Sep 19, 9:15 AM ET

    TOKYO (Reuters) – Shinzo Abe, an advocate of a more muscular Japanese foreign policy and restoring traditional values, is poised to win a party leadership contest on Wednesday, setting the stage for his election as prime minister next week.

    Abe, who turns 52 on Thursday, would be Japan’s first prime minister born after World War Two.

    He is expected to cruise to victory in the Liberal Democratic Party presidential election and be voted in as prime minister when parliament convenes on September 26.

    That will bring down the curtain on Prime Minister Junichiro Koizumi’s five-year term, during which the media-savvy, maverick leader broke Japan’s political mold with his dramatic battle against his party’s old guard for reform.

    Abe has pledged to be bold on diplomacy, rewrite Japan’s pacifist constitution and improve ties with China and South Korea, strained by Koizumi’s visits to Yasukuni Shrine.

    Beijing and Seoul see the Tokyo memorial, where wartime leaders convicted as war criminals by an Allied tribunal are honored with war dead, as a symbol of Japan’s past militarism.

    Abe has also promised to pursue growth while pressing on with the economic reforms begun by Koizumi, who leapt to power in April 2001 promising to shake up his stolid party and revive the stagnant economy by lightening government’s heavy hand.

    With Abe clearly putting priority on security and diplomatic matters and his victory seen as a done deal, pundits and market analysts are already pondering who will fill key party and cabinet posts for clearer clues to Abe’s stance on reform.

    “Abe will focus on social infrastructure, national pride and national identity rather than economic policies,” said Keio University professor Yasunori Sone. “He wants to create a resolute diplomacy, rather than stress economic reform.”

    Abe, now chief cabinet secretary, has said he wants his first overseas trip to be to an Asian country. Speculation is simmering he could meet Chinese President Hu Jintao as early as next month.

    Former Foreign Minister Nobutaka Machimura, a close Abe aide, told Reuters last week a summit with China was “very possible.”

    China has refused to hold such meetings with Koizumi since April 2005 because of his pilgrimages to Yasukuni, but analysts say Beijing is anxious to get off to a better start with Abe.

    Abe has defended Koizumi’s visits to Yasukuni and has paid his respects there in the past.

    He has declined to say whether he would go to Yasukuni as prime minister, an ambiguity some see as an effort to leave the door open for better ties with Beijing and Seoul.

    Media surveys have forecast that Abe will win around 75 percent of the votes cast in the LDP poll.

    LDP lawmakers have 403 votes while 300 are allocated to local chapters based on how rank-and-file members cast their ballots.

    The soft-spoken Abe is also popular with the general public, both for his dapper, well-bred image and his tough stance toward North Korea on the emotive issue of Japanese citizens kidnapped by Pyongyang’s agents decades ago to help train spies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s